You are currently viewing Fashola calls Atiku’s petrol subsidy plan ‘abracadabra without proof’

Fashola calls Atiku’s petrol subsidy plan ‘abracadabra without proof’

The former Lagos governor questions how the ADC candidate would fund the proposal, secure enough crude for local refineries and obtain legislative backing.

Babatunde Fashola, former governor of Lagos State, has challenged former Vice-President Atiku Abubakar to provide details of how he intends to restore petrol subsidy if elected president in 2027, describing the proposal as “abracadabra without proof”.

Fashola said Atiku had yet to explain how the proposed intervention would be funded, where the crude oil needed to sustain domestic refining would come from and how the arrangement would work within Nigeria’s existing legal framework.

He spoke on Tuesday during an interview on Channels Television’s Politics Today, where he questioned the practicality of the African Democratic Congress (ADC) presidential candidate’s proposal.

“For credibility’s sake, all major candidates, at least as at the last election, promised to remove this fuel subsidy. So what has changed?” he asked.

Fashola said politicians advocating a reversal of that position should explain what had changed and provide figures showing how their proposed policies would be sustained.

Fashola questions funding for subsidy return

The former governor, who served in the administration of former President Muhammadu Buhari, recalled that the previous subsidy arrangement reduced the revenue available to state governments.

He warned that restoring government payments on petrol could again constrain public finances, leaving states with less money to meet their obligations.

“I was in a government that was paying subsidy. And the states were not getting money. So are we going to go back to partial, near-zero returns, states borrowing money to pay salaries. Is that where you want us to go?” he asked.

Fashola urged Nigerians to consider the financial implications of the proposal, arguing that Atiku needed to show how the government would pay for the intervention.

Asked whether he considered the proposal unrealistic, he said he wanted to see detailed explanations and figures before reaching a conclusion.

“With the sketchy pronouncements that come with it, I want to see rigour, I want to see detail; I want to see numbers,” he said.

Crude oil supply raises questions

Fashola also questioned Atiku’s argument that supporting local refining would encourage competition and reduce petrol prices.

He asked how Nigeria would supply enough crude oil to domestic refineries when the country was still struggling to maximise its production capacity.

The former minister noted that Nigeria’s crude oil production involves joint ventures and production-sharing arrangements with international oil companies, meaning the country does not own all the oil produced.

He argued that the assumption that crude could simply be made available to local refineries at cheaper rates overlooked the international market value of the commodity.

Fashola also pointed to longstanding production challenges, including insecurity, vandalism and other operational problems, which he said had prevented Nigeria from fully utilising its production capacity.

“If we have refineries working, what is our current oil production quota? Are we optimising it yet? No, because there are legacy issues; there are challenges with security, vandalism, and so on and so forth, so where is this magic crude oil going to come from?” he asked.

He said Atiku must demonstrate that the country could meet the crude supply requirements of the proposed arrangement before promising lower fuel prices.

“Let people choose. But without proof, it’s like abracadabra,” Fashola said.

What Atiku’s subsidy proposal entails

Atiku announced in August 2026 that he would restore petrol subsidy if elected president in 2027. He has, however, distinguished his proposal from the former import-dependent subsidy system.

Under his proposed production subsidy model, government support would be directed at crude oil refined in Nigeria, with the aim of reducing local production costs and making petroleum products more affordable.

Atiku’s camp has described the proposed intervention as targeted, capped, transparently budgeted and independently audited. It has also argued that support would be tied to measurable domestic production rather than imported petrol.

The former vice-president has said the approach would strengthen local refining, reduce transportation and production costs, and ease the pressure of high fuel prices on households and businesses.

However, the proposal has faced questions about its funding, the volume and pricing of crude to be supplied to local refineries, and how consumers would benefit from the intervention.

Fashola’s criticism adds to the debate over the financial and operational requirements of Atiku’s proposed policy as political parties prepare for the 2027 general election.

Fattyma Ibrahim

Fattyma Zahra Ibrahim is a writer, and storyteller who believes in the power of words to inform, connect, and make people think. With a love for culture, history, and stories about society, she brings curiosity and authenticity to everything she writes. Her work reflects a belief that good storytelling should not only tell a story, but also make people pause, question, and see things from a different perspective.

Leave a Reply